Why Leaders Shouldn’t Call Themselves An Expert
January 28th, 2008 by James SchellmanI prefer not to be referred to as an expert.
Seems silly, I know. By definition, someone considered an ‘expert’ possesses a special skill or knowledge in some particular field, a specialist, or an authority. Sounds first-class and would be a badge-of-excellence anyone should be proud to wear. However, it is the connotations, not the definition, that I think of that hold me back from wishing to be an expert.
Is it just me, or have you also noticed that everyone seems to be an expert these days? I read weblogs where the author writes they are a ‘self-described expert’. That comment always provides me with a good chuckle, and is precisely why it is not the primary meaning of the word that keep me from liking it, rather, the misuse, abuse, and insinuations that are associated with it.
Don’t get me wrong, when someone refers to me as an expert, I am flattered. They are just paying me a complement; however, you will never hear me call myself an expert.
I do not want you to misunderstand, I am not trying to insult anyone who calls himself or herself an expert. I simply feel that when you refer to yourself as an expert it can hinder your ability to be a leader. Here are five reasons why being an expert can hold back your leadership’s maximum potential:
Being an expert signifies you have arrived. Do you remember the story of the turtle and the hare? The hare believes he is so fast, he becomes arrogant and overly confident and he stops to rest. (Why? Because he has arrived in his own mind.) And while he sleeps the turtle steadily pushes along and wins the race. I bet to this day, the turtle never stopped going.
Leaders should consider themselves a Turtle. They should just keep moving along, learning everything they can along the way. Why? Because when people chose to follow your example, they will only go as far as you go. As you grow and improve, so will those you lead. A leader never arrives.
Being an expert says you are a know-it-all, and have nothing left to learn. The only people I would consider calling experts were a few of my college professors. Attending college for an undergraduate degree was as much about learning new skills toward your intended profession, as it was about critical thinking. God Forbid, you ever question a thought your professor wrote in one of their personally drafted, excellently perfected textbooks. After all, you are simply an eighteen year old, and they have been around long enough to have debated with Socrates himself.
Being a Know-it-all is the Achilles Heal of leaders, because it gives off the impression:
- They are much better than the ‘little people’.
- They did it without the assistance of others.
- They arrive at their destination without others.
- They would like to separate themselves from everyone else.
Being an expert often creates close-mindedness. Aristotle once said, “It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.” When you are an close-minded, it will cause you to be defensive and protect your knowledge at all costs. How can you be open-minded when you are defensive?
Jon Wooden taught his team best when he said, “It is what you learn after you know it all that counts.”
Being an expert signifies you are above everyone else. Have you ever heard the comment, “it is lonely at the top”? Anyone who has ever been a good leader knows this is not true. When you are a leader, you surround yourself with your team and utilize the strengths of every member to complete the task. Therefore, to lead effectively you can never be above your team. Realistically, when you have a good team, who needs to be an expert?
Being an expert often leads to giving a person an ego and makes them prideful. An oversized ego or a person’s pride is their greatest enemy. When a person is prideful they are more concerned with whom is right, rather than what is right.
By contrast, Character, is a leader’s best friend. Character is the predetermined values, ethics and morals, not associated with a specific religion, culture or country, that a leader chooses to engrave into their personality.
Of those qualities, humility, may be one of the most important. Humility is the quality or condition of being humble; modest opinion or estimate of one’s own importance. When you have an ego, it directly conflicts with this quality and causes Prideful Issues:
- You will believe you can never fail.
- You will believe that rules do not apply to you.
- You will reflect a negative attitude to the team.
- You will disconnect from the team.
How can you look at yourself with a critical eye when you are egotistical and prideful?
It is my opinion, that when you refer to yourself as an expert, you will hold yourself back from achieving your greatest potential. You will mentally stall yourself and slow down your ability to grow. You may even find yourself lying by the roadside sleeping while others pass you by.
I love this quote by Earl Nightingale, I used it in one of my recent posts, “If you spend an hour a day on any given subject. After five years your will become an expert.” What he is really saying is not that after five years you will arrive and can prance around bragging about everything you know. He was really saying that growth is not a routine progression, and you should continue to grow, learn, and achieve new things - indefinately.
Isn’t that what we are all striving to do… to reach our maximum potential? In fact, that is one of the goals of this blog. To help you reach your maximum potential, and I cannot do that if I do not continue to improve. That is why you will always hear me refer to myself as a permanent student. Or sometimes, a scholar, meant in the most informal of terms: a student; pupil.
I will leave you with this quote from Paul Harvey, one of America’s most beloved storytellers, about his good friend Earl Nightingale, “Earl never let a day go by that he didn’t learn something new and, in turn, pass it on to others. It was his consuming passion.” As a leader, I hope it will be yours to.


I am writing to help leaders find their voice of influence. Plus, I like to inspire others to be their best. 




